Red Right Hand: 我的媽和她的瘋狂的外甥都, IF IT HAPPENS AGAIN...

20080327

 

我的媽和她的瘋狂的外甥都, IF IT HAPPENS AGAIN...

It should come as no surprise to anyone that I regard Firefly as some of the shiniest 天曉得 there is.

It's failure to find a sustainable audience was not surprising. It's ability to get a big damn movie was.

But I've got a little problem with some Firefly/Whedon fans. It's a rant of mine that I think bears a little ear-blistering before Dollhouse comes on as I expect it to encounter some mainstream resistance, some questionable marketing and difficulty in grabbing life-giving ratings. I'm not the only one either, as seen in this Matt Roush column. It doesn't have as much going against it (at least at first glance) as Firefly, but it could share some of the difficulties.

Just not the sci-fi/western hybrid genre. Seems like people have the hardest time getting over that hump.

First off, and this one amazes me the most, is how many people I know, near and far, who are rabid about loving the Whedon. They love him and everything he does. They watched every episode of Buffy and Angel when it was on the air.

A lot of them of didn't see Firefly until it hit DVD. A year after it was cancelled.

Whiskey Tango Foxtrot!

If you're a Whedon fan, especially a metered one, you better be there on premiere night, watching it live, not on TiVo (you're not there to watch the show, you're there to watch the commercials), and doing so every subsequent night. "Waiting for the DVD" translates as "killing the show" Especially since Fox can be itchy with the trigger finger, especially when Minear is nearby. Wonderfalls? Three eps. The Inside? Seven eps in six weeks. Drive? Four.

Another staggeringly huge amount of Whedon fans proved to be uncurious motherfuckers and we're too confused or something by the first aired episode, "The Train Job." And never watched another one until, again, the DVDs. Frakking collaborators! There's something very specific I want to address with this episode and it's effect on viewers and the problems of the airing order.

The pilot sets up the series. The pilot was not aired first. The pilot was essentially burned off at the end. I'll not get into the stupidity of all that.

Whedon and Minear knew that the pilot was not going to air first and they had the opportunity to write a new series opener and that was "The Train Job." See, it wasn't just some random episode shoved in the lead-off spot. It was written to function in the lead off spot. The bar fight teaser lays out the basics of the future in a not overly-expo way. It tells you there was the Alliance and the Independents, and that the Independent Browncoats lost. It also tells you theres animosity about that and it introduces us to Mal and we see that he was on the losing side and is not at all cool about that. We get most of the mains and we get the ship before the teaser's done.

The rest of the episode shows us through a basic heist story what our guys are about and what these Outer Worlds are like. It even goes so far as to set up a recurring bad guy. It's basically a pilot episode.

There's two kinds of pilots. Premise pilots show us the beginning of the show's concept. Lost, for instance is a premise pilot: plane crashes on the island, everything starts there. More recently, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles is a premise pilot. They get their girl Terminator protector, and move to L.A. in 2007/8. And we go from that new status quo. Random other recent examples: Eli Stone, Pushing Daisies

The West Wing is a non-premise pilot. Everything is already in place. Everyone in their jobs and the administration's been in office for a year and a half. Your average cop show has a non-premise pilot. Here's some cops doing their job, like they've always done and always will do. Other random examples: Canterbury's Law, House

"The Train Job" functions in that way. In doing so, we have a little mystery, because now we haven't seen Simon and River arrive and don't have the details of why they are wanted by the Alliance and what the deal is with that strange girl.

All that is explained in the pilot. It is also gradually explained in all the following episodes, piece by piece. In watching it air, that was one of the cool things that kept me coming back, unraveling the River enigma. It's the whole basis behind the entire Lost series.

For some reason, some people could not wrap their heads around not getting all the info all at once in the beginning. They feel they were dropped into the series in the middle of things and had to play catch up, which they totally didn't have to do.

Even if they did, does this mean they have never sampled a new series at any point other than the pilot. Most series writing staffs take great care to make each episode accessible. Not as much with highly serialized shows like 24. If you don't start 24 in the first couple or four hours, just don't bother.

Firefly was not highly serialized. Each ep had a contained reasonably A plot. I think that if I show someone (who's open to the sci-fi/western thing to start) any episode as an intro, even "Trash," in which we come upon a guest character with a history in a different episode, there should be little to no difficulty in assimilating into the world and following the story.

I don't know how many times I heard that this didn't happen. They couldn't follow the series that I had no trouble watching out of order. It was only at the end of the run, once the writing was already on the wall, where things got a little hinky, as they skipped the episode where Inara said she was leaving, but even then, it didn't stick out like a 流口水的婊子和猴子的笨儿子.

How does all this relate to Dollhouse?

Simple, Whedon fans. Watch it. No matter what happens, just watch it. And pay attention. Even if it's shown out of order, switched nights and (gawds forbid) you don't even like it at first, just keep watching it. Haven't you learned to have faith in the Whedon by now. Its broadcasty goodness will shine through.

Hell, I didn't much care for the first season of Buffy a'tall.

9 Comments:

Blogger Emily Blake said...

I was excited about the show, but where I lived it was on the same time as Farscape which was retarded scheduling. The only episode I managed to catch was "safe" so I was unimpressed.

Then when Farscape ended I watched it again and caught the pilot, which was of course the last episode they aired. I was so pissed because I loved the pilot and came back the next week wanting more.

So I'm one of those who didn't watch it much until it hit DVD.

12:54 PM  
Blogger Dave2 said...

As if anything could keep me from watching "Dollhouse"... though I have every confidence FOX will do its best to sabotage the show. It's just their nature to do so, as has been proven time and again.

1:06 AM  
Blogger Avitable said...

I wish ABC or NBC would give Joss a chance instead. Fucking Fox.

10:27 AM  
Blogger Cunningham said...

Just start the campaign now:

Make DOLLHOUSE the highest rated show in Fox history.

That's the goal. Simple. Clean. A "win" for everyone.

Now get the word out.

Because so help me, if you keep me from watching Eliza Dushku run around on my TV screen when I should be writing, there will be hell to pay.

10:41 AM  
Blogger Josh said...

Actually, and I may get killed for this, I think what Joss needs is a non-broadcast network show.

I think it highly unlikely that he's ever going to be a top 10 guy (maybe even top 20) in terms of ratings, but on a cable network he'd KILL. And not just the characters on the show.

Can you imagine how beloved he'd be (and how much freedom he'd have) if he were on FX or USA?

But really, all of this is a preamble to the day when people like Joss simply get funding from somewhere in the cosmos and individually charge us two bucks a pop on itunes and I gleefully turn over my $ like an addict.

Which, of course, I am.

5:36 PM  
Blogger m said...

I dont think you'd get killed for it, Josh. I think that Joss needs the right home for his stuff, not just "a" home.

FX is probably a better place for it, except for their trying to hue to a certain network identity (a concept I utterly despise). I think they need to dip into the more fantastic end of the pool.

The only thing I don't want to see if the pay=per-ep series. First it's one, then another, before you know it I'm paying for everything I watch individually.

I watch a fucking lot of stuff.

6:36 PM  
Blogger Shawna said...

Just wanted to point out that Tim Minear is doing his new show at ABC. It's 20th Century produced, but ABC is the network for "Miracle Man."

He has learned a lesson...

7:38 AM  
Blogger Jennica said...

Okay, gonna defend myself, because I'm one of those being indicted by this post! I watched the Firefly premiere, and then missed the rest of the show, only to fall deeply in love with it on DVD.

(Though how I'm partly responsible for killing it, when I don't have a Nielsen box in my house... there's only so much you can do without one of those li'l boxes, you know!)

The Train Job may have been intended to function as the first episode, but I'm sorry -- it's just not that great an episode of television. It doesn't knock you over, like, say, a 'War Stories'... and to lead with that was a travesty on Fox's part. But at the time, I didn't know a 2-hour pilot had been shot and bumped from the schedule. I thought The Train Job was the honest-to-God pilot, and it seemed sort of-- meh.

Why?

Because Whedon shows are all about character. Their rhythms, their language, their charming tensions. I liked them in Train Job, but the whole thing felt sort of empty to me without a real setup for the characters. If the pilot 2-parter had aired first, I'd have been full-on in love with Mal & the gang.

I'm just saying, I'm less to blame than Fox.

BUT, point taken, and I solemnly swear to watch Dollhouse faithfully.

And in case anyone's wondering about my loyalty, I just happened to have blogged recently about Serenity... which knocks me over with each repeated viewing.

10:03 AM  
Anonymous whedongeek said...

Okay, another indicted person. I came to Firefly late (no, I don't have a Nielsen box, either). I am not a Western lover, and I made the mistake of letting that drive me. Frankly, though, Fox really, really dropped the ball. Nobody programs something for Friday night without wanting it to die. I love the Whedon, and I WILL NOT make the same mistake with DOLLHOUSE. That said: I am in the process of actively converting as many Whedonites as I can. I teach over 100 students a semester in my film class, and I use the opportunity to show Buffy and Firefly, the best eps. I let them know last week that Dollhouse was filming and that they should watch it -- after they all got turned on by Firefly!!!! WOO HOO.

12:29 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home